Bloody Mary magic: How to create the ultimate Bloody Mary

Photo of author

| Published:

Learn how to make the best Bloody Mary with expert tips, secret ingredients and creative garnish ideas to satisfy your cocktail cravings. The restaurant-quality ideas in this Bloody Mary guide are easy to make at home for seasoned mixologists and brunch enthusiasts alike.

A closeup of a garnish on a Bloody Mary made with homemade Bloody Mary mix
Classic Bloody Mary. Photo credit: Feast + West.

Homemade Bloody Mary Mix

If you’re in search of the best Bloody Mary Mix, look no further than this delicious homemade version. It’s perfectly balanced with a hint of spice and lemon.
Get the Recipe: Homemade Bloody Mary Mix

Classic Bloody Mary

Let’s start with the classic. You’ll need vodka, Bloody Mary mix and a bunch of toppings to make a good old Bloody Mary. These savory cocktails are always a winner, ideally with lots of garnishes on top! You can customize this recipe with other types of alcohol, like rum, gin, tequila and whiskey.
Get the Recipe: Classic Bloody Mary

a closeup of blue cheese inside of green olives smothered in olive oil and surrounded by fresh rosemary on a blue plate.
Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives. Photo credit: Feast + West.

Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives

If you love olives AND blue cheese, this one’s for you unicorns: Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives are an easy appetizer and can also be a delicious cocktail garnish for martinis and Bloody Marys. Fill green olives with a mixture of creamy, sharp blue cheese and add them to cheese boards or cocktails — or both.
Get the Recipe: Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives

New Orleans Bloody Mary

This Bloody Mary has a Louisiana twist. Garnish it with shrimp, crawfish, fried oysters or crab hushpuppies for a Cajun seafood twist on the classic brunch drink.
Get the Recipe: New Orleans Bloody Mary

beer bottles, rim salt and hot sauce with a michelada cocktail.
Michelada. Photo credit: Feast + West.

Bloody Mary Salt

Put this flavored salt on your Bloody Mary to rim glasses and give your cocktails extra flavor! You can also put it on chicken or seafood to give it a kick.
Get the Recipe: Bloody Mary Salt

Michelada

Savory and salty, the Michelada is a delicious cocktail starring Mexican beer. Essentially a Bloody Mary made with lager beer, this is a drink you don’t want to miss.
Get the Recipe: Michelada

a jar of tequila infusing with jalapeño slices.
Jalapeño Tequila. Photo credit: Feast + West.

Jalapeño Tequila

Spice things up with this homemade, spicy Jalapeño-Infused Tequila. This recipe is a concoction with a kick and it adds tons of flavor to a Bloody Maria. Made with fresh jalapeño peppers, this spirit — your choice of tequila or mezcal — will bring all the heat.
Get the Recipe: Jalapeño Tequila

Caprese Salad Skewers

Caprese skewers are a fun appetizer, but they double as a gorgeous garnish for Bloody Marys. Skewer them ahead of time for guests to grab and add to their drinks.
Get the Recipe: Caprese Salad Skewers

closeup of garnishes on a Bloody Mary.
Bloody Derby. Photo credit: Feast + West.

Bloody Derby

The lovely Bloody Derby, which is essentially a Bloody Mary with whiskey, is worth trying. The salty flavors of the bacon and tomato juice balance out the sweetness of bourbon.
Get the Recipe: Bloody Derby

Virgin Bloody Mary

You will be surprised at how mouthwatering a Virgin Bloody Mary is! Even without alcohol, the classic brunch cocktail really shines.
Get the Recipe: Virgin Bloody Mary

Popcorn shrimp.
Popcorn shrimp. Photo credit: Feast and West

Popcorn Shrimp

Homemade popcorn shrimp is the ultimate Bloody Mary garnish. Crispy and salty, these will take your tomato drinks to the next level.
Get the Recipe: Popcorn Shrimp

Fried Pickles

Homemade fried pickles are easy to make and they make a great Bloody Mary garnish. The breading on these pickles is so tasty and crispy. Bonus: You can serve them with ranch or your favorite dipping sauce for a great snack or appetizer.
Get the Recipe: Fried Pickles

Top view of a bloody mary with celery and pickled ginger and sushi in the background.
Japanese Inspired Bloody Mary. Photo credit: Upstate Ramblings.

Japanese Inspired Bloody Mary

Hold on to your taste buds because this Japanese Inspired Bloody Mary is a fusion delight! The classic zing of a Bloody Mary gets an umami punch with the addition of sake and pickled ginger, turning this brunch staple into an adventurous flavor journey. It’s the perfect drink when you’re craving something bold and exciting; the balance of spicy, tangy, and savory is simply impeccable.
Get the Recipe: Japanese Inspired Bloody Mary

Bacon Wrapped Mini Peppers

These Bacon Wrapped Mini Peppers are stuffed with cream cheese that’s been mixed together with Everything Bagel seasoning. If you like jalapeño poppers, you’ll love these! Prepped and baked in under 1 hour, this easy Bloody Mary garnish features the perfect combination of flavor and texture.
Get the Recipe: Bacon Wrapped Mini Peppers

Smoked jalapeno poppers on a platter.
Smoked Pork Stuffed Jalapeno Poppers. Photo Credit: Cook What You Love

Bacon-Wrapped Smoked Jalapeno Poppers

Make an epic Bloody Mary and garnish it with one of these spicy, smoky, meaty poppers!
Get the Recipe: Bacon-Wrapped Smoked Jalapeno Poppers

Turkey Burger Sliders

Want an over-the-top Bloody Mary? With juicy turkey patties, crisp buns, and all your favorite toppings, this easy turkey burger slider recipe takes your favorite turkey burgers and makes them bite-sized, perfect for skewering and adding to your Bloody Mary.
Get the Recipe: Turkey Burger Sliders

Bloody mary shrimp on a white plate with a lemon wedge.
Bloody Mary Shrimp. Photo credit: Two Cloves Kitchen.

Bloody Mary Shrimp

This Bloody Mary Shrimp recipe takes the flavors from your favorite cocktail and turns it into a delicious weeknight dinner! But you can also use them as a delicious and flavorful cocktail garnish.
Get the Recipe: Bloody Mary Shrimp

Bacon-Wrapped Pickles

Your favorite dill pickle spears and wrapped in bacon and air fried to perfect crispy dill pickle appetizers. Or use them to top drinks like Bloody Marys! There’s no wrong way to enjoy them.
Get the Recipe: Bacon Wrapped Pickles

Mixed Pickles

These quick mixed pickles take any vegetable that you have on hand and turn them into bright, acidic, slightly sweet pickles in just a few minutes! They’re the perfect garnish for a Bloody Mary.
Get the Recipe: Mixed Pickles

Every Bloody Mary Garnish

An array of the best Bloody Mary garnishes on a white tabletop.
Bloody Mary Garnishes. Photo credit: Feast + West.

Want more garnish ideas for your ultimate Bloody Mary bar? Check out these creative ideas that will wow everyone at your party.
Get the List: Bloody Mary Garnishes

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.